Got an Internal Critic? Strategies for Being Less Judgmental

by

Judgment: “I lost my temper with my kids again, I am a horrible parent, and I will never get this right. I am going to screw them up.”

Non-Judgmental: “I lost my temper with the kids, I didn’t cool down before I talked to them about their bickering and messiness. I was angry because this happens a lot and felt like yelling at them. I felt frustrated and powerless. I care about them, don’t want to yell, and I want to find better ways to address this.”

Judgment: “I’m such a bore and terrible conversationalist. I sat quietly and said little while everyone else talked. No one will ever want to hang out with me.”

Non-Judgmental: “I did not speak much because most of the people at dinner tonight were new to me. I get nervous and in my head in situations like these. I felt embarrassed and self-conscious about not talking much. It was hard for me to carry on casual conversation. It may get better when I get to know some of these people more.”

These examples are to help you get started. Recognize the judgments first, then retell yourself the story using descriptive terms instead–the facts, the feelings, and the thoughts. Practice this each time you get caught up in negative judgments.

Notice When You are Judgmental

You will likely notice that there may be repetitive ways that you are are harsh and judgmental. Notice the judgments you repeatedly have and then try this exercise (write these down):

  1. Describe the judgment Do so using a factual and descriptive non-judgmental approach like above.
  2. How do I feel when I make this judgment? Write down how you feel when you get caught up in these judgments and how those feelings affect how you think about yourself.
  3. What do I do when I judge myself this way? When I judge myself this way and then feel the way I do, what do I tend to do? Do I become more effective?
  4. How would life for me be without this judgment? Think about how you would feel and what you might do without being hijacked by this judgment. Would you feel differently, would you think about yourself differently, would you persist toward your aspirations more, would you be more effective, would you feel more at ease?
  5. Write down how you could re-write the script of these judgments in a more descriptive and non-judgmental stance. How could you also apply some self-compassion to this difficult area?

Sometimes There’s More To It

Your inner critic may be too judgmental.

Sometimes there is some deeper shame connected to the judgments we make about ourselves. Sometimes there can even been some trauma connected to these judgments that make change difficult-though not impossible. It is important to note that the strategies above can be very helpful. At times, we need to do some deeper work on addressing the underlying cause of the shame that may be the source of these sticky judgments.

Be patient with yourself and practice self-compassion around these difficulties. It may be that you need professional guidance to help you navigate through this and certainly a qualified mental health clinician can help.

[/et_pb_text][/et_pb_column][/et_pb_row][/et_pb_section]

We want to take a more non-judgmental approach and actually practice modifying our self criticisms and judgments in a more non-judgmental way. We will still express what happened, how we felt, and what we thought, but use words that do not express a negative and judging attitude. Instead we can practice describing the situation factually, and write down the feelings we had, and what we were thinking about. We can practice with judgments about ourselves, others, or situations.

Here are Some Examples of Non-Judgmental Statements

Judgment: “I lost my temper with my kids again, I am a horrible parent, and I will never get this right. I am going to screw them up.”

Non-Judgmental: “I lost my temper with the kids, I didn’t cool down before I talked to them about their bickering and messiness. I was angry because this happens a lot and felt like yelling at them. I felt frustrated and powerless. I care about them, don’t want to yell, and I want to find better ways to address this.”

Judgment: “I’m such a bore and terrible conversationalist. I sat quietly and said little while everyone else talked. No one will ever want to hang out with me.”

Non-Judgmental: “I did not speak much because most of the people at dinner tonight were new to me. I get nervous and in my head in situations like these. I felt embarrassed and self-conscious about not talking much. It was hard for me to carry on casual conversation. It may get better when I get to know some of these people more.”

These examples are to help you get started. Recognize the judgments first, then retell yourself the story using descriptive terms instead–the facts, the feelings, and the thoughts. Practice this each time you get caught up in negative judgments.

Notice When You are Judgmental

You will likely notice that there may be repetitive ways that you are are harsh and judgmental. Notice the judgments you repeatedly have and then try this exercise (write these down):

  1. Describe the judgment Do so using a factual and descriptive non-judgmental approach like above.
  2. How do I feel when I make this judgment? Write down how you feel when you get caught up in these judgments and how those feelings affect how you think about yourself.
  3. What do I do when I judge myself this way? When I judge myself this way and then feel the way I do, what do I tend to do? Do I become more effective?
  4. How would life for me be without this judgment? Think about how you would feel and what you might do without being hijacked by this judgment. Would you feel differently, would you think about yourself differently, would you persist toward your aspirations more, would you be more effective, would you feel more at ease?
  5. Write down how you could re-write the script of these judgments in a more descriptive and non-judgmental stance. How could you also apply some self-compassion to this difficult area?

Sometimes There’s More To It

Your inner critic may be too judgmental.

Sometimes there is some deeper shame connected to the judgments we make about ourselves. Sometimes there can even been some trauma connected to these judgments that make change difficult-though not impossible. It is important to note that the strategies above can be very helpful. At times, we need to do some deeper work on addressing the underlying cause of the shame that may be the source of these sticky judgments.

Be patient with yourself and practice self-compassion around these difficulties. It may be that you need professional guidance to help you navigate through this and certainly a qualified mental health clinician can help.

[/et_pb_text][/et_pb_column][/et_pb_row][/et_pb_section]

Your inner critic may be too judgmental.

Do you find yourself frequently making harsh judgments about yourself? Do you frequently put yourself down when you fall short of your expectations? Have you ever noticed that the self criticisms hinder your performance and affect how you feel about yourself? Over time have you notice that self-criticism has become reflexive or even habitual, popping in your head without any effort? Well, then you may be struggling with a powerful inner critic.

Doesn’t Being Hard on Yourself Make You a Better Person?

Some believe that being self-critical and being hard on themselves will make them better people or help them achieve. This is an incorrect assumption. Self-criticism actually impedes performance and goal attainment. It leads to procrastination, increases negative rumination, and contributes to feelings of incompetency, worthlessness, and shame.

Your inner critic may be too judgmental.

If you’re feeling incompetent and worthless how likely will you be to persist through struggles, temporary setbacks, and small failures in your pursuit towards a goal or aspiration? Rather, self judgments instead contribute to a belief that setbacks and struggles are due to personal characteristics, character defects, and enduring incompetency’s. These beliefs and feelings sink our morale and belief in ourselves.

 

Well Then, What Helps?

Increasing our awareness of negative self-judgments and our tendency to explain our perceived shortcomings as being permanent aspects of ourselves (“I’m just too stupid”) is a first and critical step in changing this habit. We can’t change something that were not aware of. Many of us judge without recognizing what it is that we’re truly saying to ourselves. So we want to be mindful of how we judge ourselves.

We want to take a more non-judgmental approach and actually practice modifying our self criticisms and judgments in a more non-judgmental way. We will still express what happened, how we felt, and what we thought, but use words that do not express a negative and judging attitude. Instead we can practice describing the situation factually, and write down the feelings we had, and what we were thinking about. We can practice with judgments about ourselves, others, or situations.

Here are Some Examples of Non-Judgmental Statements

Judgment: “I lost my temper with my kids again, I am a horrible parent, and I will never get this right. I am going to screw them up.”

Non-Judgmental: “I lost my temper with the kids, I didn’t cool down before I talked to them about their bickering and messiness. I was angry because this happens a lot and felt like yelling at them. I felt frustrated and powerless. I care about them, don’t want to yell, and I want to find better ways to address this.”

Judgment: “I’m such a bore and terrible conversationalist. I sat quietly and said little while everyone else talked. No one will ever want to hang out with me.”

Non-Judgmental: “I did not speak much because most of the people at dinner tonight were new to me. I get nervous and in my head in situations like these. I felt embarrassed and self-conscious about not talking much. It was hard for me to carry on casual conversation. It may get better when I get to know some of these people more.”

These examples are to help you get started. Recognize the judgments first, then retell yourself the story using descriptive terms instead–the facts, the feelings, and the thoughts. Practice this each time you get caught up in negative judgments.

Notice When You are Judgmental

You will likely notice that there may be repetitive ways that you are are harsh and judgmental. Notice the judgments you repeatedly have and then try this exercise (write these down):

  1. Describe the judgment Do so using a factual and descriptive non-judgmental approach like above.
  2. How do I feel when I make this judgment? Write down how you feel when you get caught up in these judgments and how those feelings affect how you think about yourself.
  3. What do I do when I judge myself this way? When I judge myself this way and then feel the way I do, what do I tend to do? Do I become more effective?
  4. How would life for me be without this judgment? Think about how you would feel and what you might do without being hijacked by this judgment. Would you feel differently, would you think about yourself differently, would you persist toward your aspirations more, would you be more effective, would you feel more at ease?
  5. Write down how you could re-write the script of these judgments in a more descriptive and non-judgmental stance. How could you also apply some self-compassion to this difficult area?

Sometimes There’s More To It

Your inner critic may be too judgmental.

Sometimes there is some deeper shame connected to the judgments we make about ourselves. Sometimes there can even been some trauma connected to these judgments that make change difficult-though not impossible. It is important to note that the strategies above can be very helpful. At times, we need to do some deeper work on addressing the underlying cause of the shame that may be the source of these sticky judgments.

Be patient with yourself and practice self-compassion around these difficulties. It may be that you need professional guidance to help you navigate through this and certainly a qualified mental health clinician can help.

Your inner critic may be too judgmental.

Do you find yourself frequently making harsh judgments about yourself? Do you frequently put yourself down when you fall short of your expectations? Have you ever noticed that the self criticisms hinder your performance and affect how you feel about yourself? Over time have you notice that self-criticism has become reflexive or even habitual, popping in your head without any effort? Well, then you may be struggling with a powerful inner critic.

Doesn’t Being Hard on Yourself Make You a Better Person?

Some believe that being self-critical and being hard on themselves will make them better people or help them achieve. This is an incorrect assumption. Self-criticism actually impedes performance and goal attainment. It leads to procrastination, increases negative rumination, and contributes to feelings of incompetency, worthlessness, and shame.

Your inner critic may be too judgmental.

If you’re feeling incompetent and worthless how likely will you be to persist through struggles, temporary setbacks, and small failures in your pursuit towards a goal or aspiration? Rather, self judgments instead contribute to a belief that setbacks and struggles are due to personal characteristics, character defects, and enduring incompetency’s. These beliefs and feelings sink our morale and belief in ourselves.

 

Well Then, What Helps?

Increasing our awareness of negative self-judgments and our tendency to explain our perceived shortcomings as being permanent aspects of ourselves (“I’m just too stupid”) is a first and critical step in changing this habit. We can’t change something that were not aware of. Many of us judge without recognizing what it is that we’re truly saying to ourselves. So we want to be mindful of how we judge ourselves.

We want to take a more non-judgmental approach and actually practice modifying our self criticisms and judgments in a more non-judgmental way. We will still express what happened, how we felt, and what we thought, but use words that do not express a negative and judging attitude. Instead we can practice describing the situation factually, and write down the feelings we had, and what we were thinking about. We can practice with judgments about ourselves, others, or situations.

Here are Some Examples of Non-Judgmental Statements

Judgment: “I lost my temper with my kids again, I am a horrible parent, and I will never get this right. I am going to screw them up.”

Non-Judgmental: “I lost my temper with the kids, I didn’t cool down before I talked to them about their bickering and messiness. I was angry because this happens a lot and felt like yelling at them. I felt frustrated and powerless. I care about them, don’t want to yell, and I want to find better ways to address this.”

Judgment: “I’m such a bore and terrible conversationalist. I sat quietly and said little while everyone else talked. No one will ever want to hang out with me.”

Non-Judgmental: “I did not speak much because most of the people at dinner tonight were new to me. I get nervous and in my head in situations like these. I felt embarrassed and self-conscious about not talking much. It was hard for me to carry on casual conversation. It may get better when I get to know some of these people more.”

These examples are to help you get started. Recognize the judgments first, then retell yourself the story using descriptive terms instead–the facts, the feelings, and the thoughts. Practice this each time you get caught up in negative judgments.

Notice When You are Judgmental

You will likely notice that there may be repetitive ways that you are are harsh and judgmental. Notice the judgments you repeatedly have and then try this exercise (write these down):

  1. Describe the judgment Do so using a factual and descriptive non-judgmental approach like above.
  2. How do I feel when I make this judgment? Write down how you feel when you get caught up in these judgments and how those feelings affect how you think about yourself.
  3. What do I do when I judge myself this way? When I judge myself this way and then feel the way I do, what do I tend to do? Do I become more effective?
  4. How would life for me be without this judgment? Think about how you would feel and what you might do without being hijacked by this judgment. Would you feel differently, would you think about yourself differently, would you persist toward your aspirations more, would you be more effective, would you feel more at ease?
  5. Write down how you could re-write the script of these judgments in a more descriptive and non-judgmental stance. How could you also apply some self-compassion to this difficult area?

Sometimes There’s More To It

Your inner critic may be too judgmental.

Sometimes there is some deeper shame connected to the judgments we make about ourselves. Sometimes there can even been some trauma connected to these judgments that make change difficult-though not impossible. It is important to note that the strategies above can be very helpful. At times, we need to do some deeper work on addressing the underlying cause of the shame that may be the source of these sticky judgments.

Be patient with yourself and practice self-compassion around these difficulties. It may be that you need professional guidance to help you navigate through this and certainly a qualified mental health clinician can help.

Related Articles

How Nature Soothes Us

How Nature Soothes Us

  Being out in nature is one of the best ways to destress and manage your mental health. Multiple studies have showcased the healing benefits of nature. It reduces stress, improves your mood, and can help with issues like depression and anxiety. If there was one...

read more
Could You be a Compulsive Shopper?

Could You be a Compulsive Shopper?

What is compulsive shopping? It’s not uncommon to treat yourself to a shopping trip every now and then. You might even feel a burst of happiness when you make a purchase, or you’re able to get something you really want. The idea of ‘retail therapy’ is really something...

read more
Body Image: Loving the Skin You’re In

Body Image: Loving the Skin You’re In

Body image is more than just body positivity and focusing on loving your appearance. An important part of body image goes much deeper. There’s nothing wrong with loving the way you look. When you see yourself in a mirror, you should be confident in your appearance and...

read more
Managing Emotional Burnout

Managing Emotional Burnout

You’ve probably heard of getting burnt out by things like work or extra responsibilities. But, have you ever heard of emotional burnout? It’s more common than you might think and occurs when what's draining you is more than what you are “depositing” into your overall...

read more
Learning to “Practice the Pause”

Learning to “Practice the Pause”

There’s no denying that we live in a busy, hectic society that rarely slows down to take a pause. It’s easy to fall into the pressure “trap” of trying to always be "productive" or packing your schedule too full.  Unfortunately, that’s become the norm for far too many...

read more
Coping with Grief During the Holidays

Coping with Grief During the Holidays

  The holidays are supposed to be a time filled with joy, laughter, and excitement. But, if you’re experiencing a loss around any holiday, it’s difficult to feel that kind of joy that those around you might be sharing. Grief around the holidays isn’t uncommon....

read more
Assertive Communication Skills: How to Find Your Voice

Assertive Communication Skills: How to Find Your Voice

Some people think of being assertive as the same as being aggressive. They might not want to “come off” a certain way, so they hold themselves back from speaking what’s really on their heart and mind. The reality? Assertiveness is often helpful. But, that doesn’t make...

read more
Animals Make Us Better: Exploring the Power of Pets

Animals Make Us Better: Exploring the Power of Pets

  There have been multiple studies to show the mental and physical health benefits of pets. It has even been found that simply being around a dog or petting it can boost your mood and make you feel better. That’s one reason why pet therapy has become so popular...

read more
How to Choose to NOT be Offended

How to Choose to NOT be Offended

It is human nature and so easy to become offended. Someone may say something that rubs you the wrong way. Maybe what they say feels like an “attack” on something you’ve done or that you value. Sometimes it's necessary to evaluate your role in being offended. This is...

read more
Breaking Free from Anxiety and Analysis Paralysis

Breaking Free from Anxiety and Analysis Paralysis

  It’s not uncommon to have a hard time making certain decisions. Some people struggle with it more than others. But, "analysis paralysis" takes that to extremes. Analysis paralysis occurs when your underlying anxiety makes it impossible to make a decision....

read more